Day 82: Response Bias Project
I just want to thank Josh Wilkerson once again for helping me create meaningful experiences for my AP Statistics students. As I mentioned earlier this year, I am hoping to replicate his Community Service Learning Project as the end of year experience for my students.
One suggestion Josh gave was to give two smaller projects during first semester to see how students work together. I have found that they also give opportunities for the students to revisit previous concepts in a real world setting. In first quarter, my students completed an Infographics Project. In second quarter, I had them complete the Response Bias Project he suggested. And I love the results!!
The projects were due today. As part of the evaluation process, students needed to complete a peer review of 4 other projects. I used GoogleForms for students to enter their evaluations as well as include comments. They had about 8 minutes to read through the poster and evaluate it. I thought they’d need 10 minutes, but they didn’t
What I like about the Google Form is it is easy to make accessible to my students, by using our school login I get an automatic signature and the students can keep resubmitting the form. In addition, the results end up in an Excel spreadsheet so I can then add up the totals, sort by student being evaluated as well as those who did the evaluating.
Student earned points from the average of their peers’ evaluations as well as points for thoughtful and meaningful evaluations of their peers. I now hope to merge the comments into a personalized Word document so each student can get their peers’ feedback anonymously. Here are a few of the peer comments:
- Originally I liked the idea of flaps but as soon as I had to reach on my tippy toes to hold the flap up I grew tired of it. Then I took the poster down from the wall and I liked the design again.
The plentiful analysis in the conclusions is good and clear. I’m surprised 20 males said they didn’t support feminism, especially since we’re talking about XXHS students!
- I like how you chose a topic extremely relevant to all of us. You did a good job explaining the difference in the questions and why that would elicit different responses. Don’t forget your table! Do you think underclassmen would give different results? I might interview them too in order to remove bias.
- I thought the experiment was very well thought out and thorough. You lovely duo did a great job articulating your points. Maybe in the future you should experiment with whether putting one of the names first affects the results? I might also put less text and more visual stuff on the poster. Great job though
- I feel like the questions are a little vague, as they could present a large amount of bias. Some students might not like the teachers, even though they are learning a lot and they are satisfied with the learning, prompting more “no” answers than should be present. However, I love the organization of this poster, it is very neat.
- I like how you captured an interesting concept (extra information bias) very simply. But, given that your population is American Women, I think it is statistically incorrect that you only found samples from XXXXX’s Facebook contacts who do not represent all American women. A better population would have been Teenage girls in XXXXXXXXX.
I love how my students used the statistical vocabulary with ease and relatively correctly! This project is definitely a keeper.